Hunting for the best bagels in Toms River, NJ sharpens your senses. It’s the glossy crackle as you tear into a fresh bagel, the cloud-soft crumb, and that faint scent of yeast in a bustling shop at dawn. Once, I ducked into a local spot before sunrise, and the steam rising from a warm everything bagel—just out of the oven—got my attention before I’d even ordered a coffee. Moments like that turn ordinary mornings into quiet celebrations.
Toms River spoils you with choices. With classic delis, family-run bakeries, and specialty bagel shops scattered across town, each spot claims its own loyal fans and signature twist. Whether you crave a perfectly plain round or obsess over creative flavors, there’s a bagel here waiting to win you over. We’re about to map out the must-try stops, so you can find your next go-to bagel, right down to that last poppy seed.
1. Manhattan Bagel
Manhattan Bagel on Hooper Ave knows how to do mornings right. Stepping inside, the warm aroma of fresh-baked bagels wraps around you. Watching the bakers in action, shaping and boiling dough by hand, you sense their devotion to the classic New York style.
Their bagels are perfectly chewy and deeply flavorful. The sesame and everything bagels hit that authentic, golden-brown mark many try to imitate but few get right. If you’re hungry, order a hot egg sandwich on an everything bagel. The texture is spot-on, the flavors balanced, and it’s just messy enough to feel like a real treat.
For lunch, their freshly made veggie or tuna salads on a bagel make great options. Everything is made fresh, right on the spot.
2. Manhattan Bagel
The Manhattan Bagel on Route 37 E always captures that classic neighborhood bakery vibe. Morning regulars shuffle in for bagels so fresh they’re still warm, and it’s easy to see why so many locals return each day. The shop bustles, but service is swift and cheerful, making it an ideal stop when you’re on the move.
These bagels stand out for their soft-yet-chewy texture and rich, yeasty flavor. The egg bagel is especially memorable—velvety yellow, subtly sweet, and a perfect base for any breakfast sandwich.
I recommend ordering a plain or whole wheat bagel, paired with scallion cream cheese. The freshness and tang of the spread lets the quality of the bagel shine through, keeping the spotlight on true NJ bagel craft.
3. All Star Bagel
All Star Bagel on Route 37 W lives up to its name. This cozy spot keeps a steady stream of regulars who swear by their hand-rolled bagels and inviting atmosphere. My first visit was early on a rainy morning, and the scent alone set the tone for a genuinely good breakfast.
The bagels here are dense yet tender, with a lightly crisp exterior and just the right chew. For a classic experience, try a salt bagel with plain cream cheese, which lets you appreciate the craftsmanship behind each batch.
If you want something heartier, their bagel egg sandwiches are filling and always fresh. All Star Bagel delivers on quality and comfort, making it a favorite among Toms River locals.
4. New York Water Bagel Co
New York Water Bagel Co on Fischer Blvd draws bagel enthusiasts craving the genuine article. They use real New York water in their dough, a detail that sets the texture apart. The result is a bagel with crackling crust and a soft bite—one that stands out in a town packed with competition.
The everything bagel is always a solid pick, layered with poppy seeds, garlic, and onion. There’s a slight tang, balanced with that signature chew you expect from top-tier bagels. Morning lines move quickly, but you’ll notice people linger to enjoy the friendly buzz inside.
For something fresh, combine a sesame bagel with their house-made veggie cream cheese. New York Water Bagel Co values quality, and every bite shows it.
5. Terrys Not Just Bagels
Terry’s Not Just Bagels is a little roadside spot known for its reliable, homey feel. The first thing that hits you is the scent of bread baking fresh from early morning. You’ll spot regulars chatting with staff, which gives the place a neighborly charm you don’t see everywhere.
Their bagels are soft inside with a slight crisp to the outer layer. The rye bagel stands out—sturdy, earthy, and a solid choice for any fan of old-school flavor. Order it toasted with chive cream cheese for an easy breakfast that doesn’t skimp on taste.
If you’re after something lighter, the whole wheat bagel paired with a simple schmear is fresh and satisfying, perfect for anyone who likes their mornings easy and unfussy.
6. Silver Bay Bagels
Silver Bay Bagels sits in the Silverton Shopping Center, serving up some of the most consistently fresh bagels in town. Step inside early and you’ll catch racks of warm, handmade bagels just as they’re set out. The staff are laid-back and quick to know your order after a few visits. There’s a sense of routine here that’s oddly comforting.
Their cinnamon raisin bagel comes highly recommended—sweet, chewy, with raisins in every bite. For bagel purists, the poppy is both crisp and satisfying, best enjoyed with a classic cream cheese schmear.
If you want something simple and quick for breakfast, their whole wheat bagel is hearty and always fresh. Silver Bay Bagels does comfort food right, one bagel at a time.
7. All Star Bagels
All Star Bagels on Route 37 W serves as a go-to spot for many bagel fans in Toms River. The aroma of their freshly baked bagels fills the shop and seems to follow you home. Regulars appreciate the uncomplicated ordering process and fast service even when the line stretches to the door.
There’s something satisfying about their jalapeño bagel—chewy, with a subtle, pleasant heat. Pair it with garden veggie cream cheese for a flavor combination that wakes up any morning. Each bagel has the right texture, a good crust, and a fluffy center that defines great bagel-making.
If you’re out for a filling lunch, their egg and cheese bagel sandwich is classic and always satisfying. All Star Bagels has built its name on consistency, freshness, and a local touch.
8. Joe’s Bagel and Grill
Joe’s Bagel and Grill in the TJ Maxx Plaza brings a New Jersey twist to classic bagel fare. Each bagel is hand-rolled, boiled, and baked, making a clear statement about quality. My first visit was mid-morning, and the steady flow of both families and office-goers says a lot about its reputation.
Their bagel selection covers all the bases, but the asiago bagel is a stand-out—savory and golden, with a hint of cheese in every bite. Try it with their scallion cream cheese or go all in with a made-to-order egg white and veggie omelet on your bagel of choice.
Joe’s also offers hearty lunch options, but the simple pleasure of a fresh, still-warm bagel here makes mornings better. It’s the mark of a shop that values tradition and taste.
9. Bakin Bagels
Bakin Bagels on Atlantic City Blvd draws early risers and devoted regulars for good reason. The staff greets you with genuine warmth, even before your first cup of coffee. There’s an energy here that makes grabbing breakfast feel like a small occasion every time.
Their blueberry bagel is a highlight—bursting with fruit and a little hint of sweetness that stays with you. Toasted and slathered with plain cream cheese, it’s the kind of breakfast that’s hard to beat. The texture is spot-on, soft inside and never dry.
On busy weekends, people line up for their egg and cheese bagel sandwiches, which are filling and perfectly seasoned. Bakin Bagels stands out for freshness, flavor, and a welcoming vibe.
10. T R Bagels
(732) 244-2400Call
T R Bagels, found on Atlantic City Blvd, gives off that classic, old-school bagel shop feel. Stepping inside, the inviting smell of fresh dough sets the expectation for quality. There’s a certain comfort in the way the staff knows the names—and favorite orders—of their regulars.
The bagels strike a balance of being chewy with the right amount of golden crust. Their onion bagel stands out, robust and fragrant, carrying just the right aroma and flavor. Eat it warm with plain or veggie cream cheese for a simple, satisfying start to the day.
T R Bagels keeps things genuine and straightforward, offering a great selection in an atmosphere that keeps regulars returning week after week.
Frequently Asked Questions
What makes bagels in Toms River, NJ unique?
Bagels in Toms River are known for their classic New York style—boiled, then baked for a dense, chewy bite and a crisp crust. Many local shops hand-roll and bake fresh batches daily, keeping traditions alive with every bagel.
Are there vegan or dairy-free bagel options in Toms River?
Yes, many bagel shops offer plain, sesame, poppy, and other bagels that are naturally dairy-free and vegan. Always ask staff about ingredients or specialty spreads.
Which bagel flavors are most popular in Toms River?
The top picks are usually everything, sesame, plain, cinnamon raisin, and onion. Each shop often has its own specialty flavors worth a try.
Can I find gluten-free bagels in Toms River, NJ?
A few local bakeries and cafes offer gluten-free bagels, but selections may be limited. Call ahead or check menus online to be sure.
Which spots are best for a quick bagel breakfast?
Silver Bay Bagels, Manhattan Bagel, and All Star Bagel are favorites for a fast and satisfying breakfast. Service is typically efficient during busy mornings.