If you judge a town by its bagels, Port Jervis leaves quite the impression. Surrounded by the rolling green of the tri-state area, this small city punches above its weight when it comes to chewy, golden rounds of doughy delight. I still remember wandering Main Street one crisp autumn morning, following the scent of fresh-baked bagels that mingled with the snap of cool air. The first bite was all crunch, then a soft, warm center—simple, honest, and unforgettable.
Finding a great bagel should be easy, but not all are created equal. Knowing where to go matters if you crave a perfect crust and just the right chew. That’s what you’ll get in this guide. With years of noshing and more than a few heated debates over “the best,” I’ve sifted through the hype to highlight the standouts worth your time. Ready to discover the best bagels in Port Jervis? Keep reading; your next favorite spot may be just around the corner.
1. Bagel Station Deli
Bagel Station Deli, on the corner of Main Street, draws you in with the smell of fresh bagels drifting through the door. Mornings here are a local ritual—I remember ducking in to warm up and leaving convinced their bagels were made with a secret ingredient. Each bagel arrives with a chewy crust and soft middle, the hallmark of good craftsmanship.
The menu is straightforward, but every option feels like the right one. The classic plain bagel with scallion cream cheese delivers old-school comfort. The everything bagel, loaded with seeds, carries a satisfying crunch in every bite. Don’t skip the egg and cheese bagel sandwich; it’s the city’s quiet breakfast champion.
Bagel Station Deli knows how to make mornings better—one bagel at a time.
2. The Bagel Barn
The Bagel Barn, tucked on Pike Street, plays up the charm of a neighborhood favorite. My first visit was on a rainy morning, and the warm, yeasty aroma made the day brighter before I even tasted a thing. Every bagel here has a golden finish and authentic, kettle-boiled chew that signals real care.
The atmosphere is relaxed—friendly chatter mixing with the whir of coffee. If you crave a New York-style classic, their sesame bagel is always crisp and nutty. Their cinnamon raisin bagel, slathered with house-made maple walnut spread, hits all the right comforting notes.
The Bagel Barn excels by keeping things honest, local, and irresistibly fresh. You’ll taste the difference with every bite.
3. Dunkin’
(845) 856-7513Call
Dunkin’ on East Main Street is the town’s steady option for a quick bagel fix. Whether you’re heading out early or need an afternoon recharge, the staff keeps things moving with familiar efficiency. No fuss, no surprises—just fresh bagels and piping hot coffee.
I’ve ducked in more than once, drawn by the convenience and consistently soft bagels. Their multigrain bagel, hearty yet not heavy, pairs well with a light veggie spread. The plain bagel, toasted and filled with egg and cheese, is an easy go-to when you need comfort food fast.
Dunkin’ may be part of a chain, but here in Port Jervis, it delivers dependability and that reliable bagel bite you know.
4. Carmine’s Italian American Bakery
(845) 856-4195Call
Carmine’s Italian American Bakery, nestled on Front Street, is where tradition meets small-town warmth. I wandered in chasing the smell of fresh bread, and left with an armful of bagels that proved impossible to resist. Their bagels blend old-world recipes with a soft, pillowy interior you won’t find anywhere else.
Here, there’s pride in every batch. The sesame bagel offers a nutty finish, while their garlic bagel boasts a subtle savor that lingers. Try the whole wheat bagel for a lighter touch—balanced, hearty, and perfect with classic cream cheese.
Carmine’s is more than a bakery; it’s an anchor for anyone serious about bagels with a nod to Italian roots.
5. Daredevil Deli
Daredevil Deli, just over the river in Sussex, brings bagel craft and whimsical flair to breakfast. I wandered in on a whim and found a place where the regulars chat with staff and the air buzzes with friendly banter. Every bagel is made in-house, baked fresh each morning, which means there’s always something warm from the oven.
The real draw is in their specialty sandwiches. The “Double Dare” is a challenge worth accepting, loaded with eggs and cheese on a bagel of your choice. Rotating “Feature” bagels make every visit a surprise, but the cheddar jalapeño is a personal favorite for its bold, savory kick.
Daredevil Deli’s playful spirit, fresh-baked approach, and creative menu make it a must for anyone on a bagel hunt around Port Jervis.
6. C & D’s Old World Bagels
(845) 981-7156Call
C & D’s Old World Bagels in Pine Island is a bit of a drive from Port Jervis, but it’s worth every mile for real-deal bagel lovers. I made the trip myself and found a spot where tradition truly matters. Bagels here are hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and baked to a deep, golden finish the Old World way.
The menu is classic, but the details stand out. Try the pumpernickel bagel; its robust, earthy flavor is perfect with their plain cream cheese. The salt bagel calls for a generous swipe of veggie spread—simple, but undeniably satisfying.
If you’re after authentic texture and a bit of nostalgia, C & D’s delivers time after time with every bite.
7. Downtown Bagels
Downtown Bagels in Middletown feels like every good bakery should—bustling in the morning, with the comforting scent of dough and coffee. I once popped in during the breakfast rush, and the line moved fast, fueled by regulars and their favorite orders. Bagels here are thick, with a glossy crust and a dense interior that never disappoints.
The standout? The sunflower bagel, warm and speckled with seeds, paired with a honey walnut spread for a delicious balance of sweet and savory. If you want a true breakfast sandwich, their egg and cheese on a jalapeño bagel is unmatched for both flavor and heartiness.
Downtown Bagels keeps loyal locals coming back, and it’s easy to taste why after just one visit.
8. The Bagel Shop & Deli
The Bagel Shop & Deli in Middletown has all the charm and bustle you want in a proper breakfast spot. My last trip was on a chilly Saturday—the line curved out the door, but the servers made everyone feel right at home. The bagels are boiled and baked, giving them that signature bite and springy texture.
The rainbow bagel is a visual delight and surprisingly hearty: pair it with their homemade veggie cream cheese for a treat that’s as fun as it is tasty. Their whole wheat bagel, toasted and loaded with egg and cheese, is another choice that never steers you wrong.
This is where locals go for classic flavor and a warm start to the day.
9. Orange County Bagel Bakery
Orange County Bagel Bakery, tucked on Dolson Avenue in Middletown, is the kind of place that turns first-timers into regulars. The smell alone—warm dough and toasted seeds—had me hooked before I could scan the full menu. Bagels here are soft on the inside with a golden crust, just the thing to chase away a groggy morning.
Their egg bagel is unforgettable: rich, slightly sweet, and ideal when paired with a swipe of their chive cream cheese. Don’t miss the onion bagel, which manages to be savory yet light—perfect for a classic bagel and lox (without crossing into haram territory).
Efficient, friendly service and reasonable prices complete the appeal. Orange County Bagel Bakery is a spot you’ll keep returning to.
10. Bagel Tree
Bagel Tree in Sussex is well worth the short drive from Port Jervis for anyone chasing classic New York-style bagels. The first time I stopped by, just after sunrise, the bakery hum was already in full swing. Bagels here are hand-rolled and kettle-boiled, with a satisfying crust and hearty interior.
Their asiago bagel is a must—crisp cheese on top melds with the chewy dough beneath. If you want comfort, go for the blueberry bagel with plain cream cheese; it hits all the right morning notes.
Bagel Tree’s cozy atmosphere and clear pride in their craft make this spot a memorable addition to any breakfast rotation.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Where can I find the best bagels in Port Jervis, NY?
Bagel Station Deli and The Bagel Barn are top local favorites, known for their chewy, golden bagels. For variety, check out options in nearby Middletown or Sussex.
2. Are there gluten-free bagels available in Port Jervis?
Some bakeries may offer gluten-free bagels, but it’s best to call ahead. Places like The Bagel Barn occasionally feature gluten-free varieties depending on demand.
3. What’s a typical price for a bagel with cream cheese?
You’ll usually spend $2 to $4 for a bagel with cream cheese at most local spots. Specialty bagels or gourmet spreads may cost a little extra.
4. Which bagel shops offer breakfast sandwiches?
Almost every spot on the list—especially Bagel Station Deli, The Bagel Barn, and Daredevil Deli—serves breakfast sandwiches built on fresh bagels.
5. Can I get bagels made without animal-based ingredients in Port Jervis?
Yes. Many bakeries offer plain or specialty bagels without animal-based ingredients, especially if you stick to classic dough and vegetable spreads. Always double-check if you have dietary preferences.
6. Do any of these shops offer catering or large orders?
Yes, spots like Downtown Bagels and Orange County Bagel Bakery can accommodate party platters and big orders. Call ahead to discuss details and options.
7. Which bagel flavor is most popular in Port Jervis?
Everything bagels and sesame bagels are tried-and-true favorites throughout the area. If you’re new, start with one of these for a taste of local style.