Finding the perfect bagel in Riverhead, NY is a bit like hunting for a hidden gem at a beach—locals know where to look, but newcomers need a little guidance. I first wandered into a Riverhead bagel shop on a drizzly morning, the smell of fresh dough in the air. That first bite—slightly crisp on the outside, soft and chewy inside—made me a believer. Since then, sampling bagels here has become a full-fledged pursuit.
The Riverhead area lines up an impressive cast of bagel spots, each with its own signature touch and devoted regulars. Whether you lean toward a classic plain with a smudge of cream cheese or chase something more adventurous, like an everything bagel dressed up with fresh lox, you’ll find something to make breakfast feel anything but basic. This guide highlights the very best bagels in Riverhead, sorted with care and a discerning palate. Prepare to discover not just where to find these winning bagels, but what gives each shop its claim to fame.
1. Signature Bagels Deli
+1 631-208-8584
At Signature Bagels Deli, fresh-baked bagels aren’t just breakfast—they’re morning therapy. I still remember my first visit: the inviting aroma of warm bread met me at the door, and a regular insisted I try their sesame bagel. One bite and I got it; the texture is what sets them apart, soft inside with just the right chew.
Signature Bagels Deli feels cozy, with quick, friendly service whether you’re rushing in for breakfast or settling in for brunch. The place is wheelchair accessible, so everyone can enjoy their menu.
Their flagship is the classic everything bagel with scallion cream cheese. It’s a no-nonsense pairing that showcases why regulars keep coming back. Bagel sandwiches here are equally tempting if you want a hearty lunch.
2. Bagel Lovers Cafe
Bagel Lovers Cafe knows how to charm both newcomers and seasoned bagel fans. On my last visit, I grabbed a window seat and watched the staff work through a steady flow of regulars, each greeted by name. That sort of warmth is built into the soul of the place.
The bagels here are always fluffy, never dry, with a chew that holds up whether you eat them plain or dressed up. Their consistency sets them apart in Riverhead.
If you want a recommendation, don’t skip the cinnamon raisin bagel, lightly toasted with plain cream cheese. It’s a simple order that highlights just how fresh their bagels are. If you’re lingering for lunch, the veggie bagel sandwich is always a satisfying winner.
3. Goldbergs Famous Bagels
Goldbergs Famous Bagels is the kind of spot that makes you understand why people care so much about bagels. The first time I stopped by, I was struck by how bustling the place gets each morning. Locals pack the line, eyeing the trays of shiny, just-baked bagels.
This shop balances tradition and flavor, sticking to the classic New York bagel formula: golden crust, tender interior, and heaps of choice. Each bagel here tastes like it belongs on a city street corner, minus the noise.
For the real Goldbergs experience, try their poppy seed bagel with lox spread. The contrast of soft bagel and creamy topping is the definition of satisfying. For a simple win, go for a classic salt bagel with plain cream cheese.
4. Strathmore Bagel Cafe
Strathmore Bagel Cafe is the kind of place that makes weekdays feel like a treat. I wandered in on a rainy morning and was greeted by the comfort only a warm, perfectly baked bagel can offer. The staff works with impressive speed, yet every order feels personal.
The menu covers all the bagel basics, but their quality is far from ordinary. Every bagel is baked with that slight New York crunch and a doughy, satisfying middle.
The whole wheat everything bagel here is a best-kept secret. It’s hearty enough to stand on its own but shines with a thick layer of chive cream cheese. If you’re eating lunch, their bagel melts hit the spot—always made fresh, always satisfying.
5. Riverhead Bagels
Riverhead Bagels is one of those hidden gems tucked right on Main Street. I first found it while exploring the neighborhood, drawn in by the visible stacks of bagels cooling behind the counter. You can always count on the staff to be friendly and the service to move fast—even during the breakfast rush.
What makes Riverhead Bagels special is a focus on freshness. Every bagel feels like it just left the oven. If you enjoy variety, you’ll appreciate their classic lineup alongside a few creative flavors.
The onion bagel here is fantastic, especially paired with a thick smear of veggie cream cheese. For something heartier, their bagel breakfast sandwiches offer a satisfyingly simple start to any day.
6. East End Bagels
(631) 722-7889Call
East End Bagels may be easy to overlook, but those in the know never miss a chance to swing by. I first stopped here on a morning drive and was won over by the sunny attitude behind the counter and the near-endless bagel choices.
The bagels have a satisfying bite—crispy edges and a pillowy center that’s clearly baked to perfection. This spot is all about classic quality done right, skipping the frills but never the essentials.
The plain bagel with fresh whipped cream cheese is as straightforward as it gets, but that’s where East End Bagels shines. For a little more punch, try a salt bagel toasted and topped with their house-made spreads. Simple, but memorable.
7. Dunkin’
Dunkin’ brings convenience and predictability to the heart of Riverhead. When I’m in a hurry and need breakfast on the go, this spot is a reliable choice. The familiar orange-and-pink sign draws in morning commuters and road-trippers alike.
Dunkin’s bagels always hit that consistent note—nicely toasted, lightly crisp, and dependable every single visit. While the offerings are classic, they’re efficient at what they do: quick service, clean options, and plenty of choices for bagel lovers.
A favorite order here is the classic sesame bagel with plain cream cheese; it’s simple but always delivers, especially with a hot cup of Dunkin’s famous coffee. If you want something heartier, their bagel breakfast sandwiches are both filling and familiar.
8. Black Sheep Bagels
Black Sheep Bagels brings a fresh approach to bagels on the North Fork, and it never feels afraid to be a little different. My first visit left an impression—there’s a small-town friendliness, and even the usual bagel varieties come with a creative twist.
The bagels here are boiled and baked the old-school way, but topped and filled with real flair. Every bagel boasts a satisfying structure, and the flavors last from the first bite to the last crumb.
Try their rosemary sea salt bagel with veggie cream cheese for something you’ll remember long after your visit. The combination shows off Black Sheep’s signature style: classic technique, modern taste. For lunch, their bagel sandwiches pack both substance and flavor.
9. Princess Bagels
(631) 996-4445Call
Princess Bagels adds a bit of local charm to the stretch of Montauk Highway. I stumbled in one Saturday morning, greeted by a display of golden bagels just out of the oven—a sight every bagel lover appreciates. Even on busy days, their service stays friendly and efficient.
The shop takes pride in traditional methods, but their menu isn’t afraid of a little surprise. Every bagel at Princess is soft yet sturdy, just the right bite for any spread or sandwich.
The egg bagel with scallion cream cheese is a top pick, creamy and flavorful all at once. For a midday treat, the classic poppy seed bagel also holds up well as a base for any of their savory cream cheeses.
10. Goldberg’s Famous Bagels
Goldberg’s Famous Bagels on Montauk Highway has a way of drawing in early risers and breakfast regulars. My visit started with the comforting sight of bakers kneading dough behind the counter and the steady hum of satisfied customers. Goldberg’s keeps things both classic and neighborly.
The shop’s reputation is built on a time-honored recipe: shiny crust, chewy inside, and a lineup of bagels that never seem to disappoint. Friendly service keeps the morning pace pleasant, no matter how crowded it gets.
The sesame bagel with plain cream cheese is the definition of dependable—a simple order that’s done remarkably well. If you’re in the mood to linger, their whole wheat bagel with veggie cream cheese is another solid choice that’s equally popular with regulars.
Frequently Asked Questions
What makes bagels in Riverhead unique?
Riverhead bagels are known for their classic New York style—crisp outside, chewy inside—and a local flair that comes from skilled bakers using time-tested methods. Each shop often adds a signature twist, from creative spreads to unique bagel varieties.
Are there vegetarian options available at bagel shops in Riverhead?
Absolutely. Most shops offer vegetarian choices, with a range of spreads (like veggie or chive cream cheese) and veggie-packed bagel sandwiches. Freshness is key, so even a simple bagel and cream cheese can feel like a meal.
Which bagel flavors are most popular in Riverhead?
Favorites include everything, sesame, and plain bagels. Some local spots also shine with creative flavors such as rosemary sea salt or whole wheat everything, giving regulars new favorites to discover.
Can I get gluten-free bagels in Riverhead?
Some bagel cafes carry gluten-free options, but it’s best to call ahead and check. Selections may be limited, yet most shops accommodate different dietary needs as best they can.
When is the best time to visit local bagel shops?
Early mornings are your best bet for the freshest selection and shorter lines. Many locals grab their bagels before work, making the atmosphere brisk but lively.