Bagels can be a bit of an adventure, especially in Fountain, CO, where small-town charm meets big cravings. Finding that perfect bagel—one that balances chew and crust while settling in with just the right amount of flavor—is more of a quest than a casual errand. My last hunt for the best bagel in town started with a morning chill, an empty stomach, and a simple goal: to find the kind of breakfast that makes you pause mid-bite.
Exploring local spots, I met bakers who still believe baking is an art form and baristas who’ll chat bagel pairings while pouring a fresh cup. The hunt revealed hidden gems and familiar favorites, each offering their own spin on a classic staple. If you’re after the top bagels in Fountain or curious about where the locals go, this guide has you covered with honest picks and a sprinkle of bagel insight.
1. Dunkin’
Dunkin’ at Mesa Ridge Parkway is where early mornings collide with quick convenience. What makes Dunkin’ stand out is its reliable consistency and fast service, a welcome presence for anyone racing the morning rush. The cream cheese bagel twist is the sleeper hit, delivering that classic chew with a smooth, savory finish.
During my visit, the everything bagel with veggie cream cheese became my pick. Each bite had that signature Dunkin’ texture—you know you’re eating a proper bagel, not just round bread. Pair it with a cold brew for an energizing start. Dunkin’ is perfect when you want familiar flavors that hit the spot every time.
You can order online or in-store, making the experience even more hassle-free.
2. Olde World Bagel
Olde World Bagel offers a cozy taste of tradition just north of Fountain, in Colorado Springs. The bagels here carry that unmistakable old-school chew and tang you only get from hand-rolled, boiled dough. It’s the kind of spot where the aroma hits you before you reach the door, instantly kicking up the appetite.
On my last visit, the standout was the sesame bagel with their house-made plain cream cheese. The slight crunch of sesame mixed with the warmth of fresh-baked dough is a combination few can match. There’s a clear commitment to quality, from the simple classics to playful options like spinach parmesan.
If you enjoy a deli-style breakfast or lunch, their loaded bagel sandwiches are generous and filling. Olde World Bagel is a must for anyone craving a genuine bagel experience without shortcuts.
3. Einstein Bros. Bagels
Einstein Bros. Bagels blends friendly vibes with the comfort of a bakery you can trust. There’s something inviting about watching trays of bagels move from oven to counter, each one warm and golden. This spot is ideal for grabbing breakfast downtown or taking a bag of bagels to share.
I always circle back to their asiago cheese bagel. The fresh, tangy cheese on crisp dough feels just right—simple, satisfying, and hearty. Paired with their garden veggie shmear, it’s a dependable combo for busy mornings.
Besides bagels, Einstein Bros. offers a full lineup of breakfast sandwiches, all customizable. If you like options, this place keeps things simple but never dull. It’s reliability baked into every batch.
4. Coffee & Bagel Corner
Coffee & Bagel Corner is that under-the-radar café where regulars exchange nods and newcomers feel at home fast. Here, you’ll find bagels made fresh each day, often still warm when they hit your table. The place hums with local chatter, adding to its charm.
I tried the classic poppy seed bagel with their light chive cream cheese. The combination captured everything good about a simple bagel: soft crumb, a little crunch, and flavors that linger. Their straightforward menu focuses on essentials, keeping quality at the center.
If you’re after a cozy spot in Colorado Springs for coffee and a genuine bagel, this is the place to unwind—or just refuel on a busy day.
5. Bruegger’s
(719) 635-8548Call
Bruegger’s brings classic bagel-making to the heart of downtown, marrying New York tradition with neighborhood comfort. Their open kitchen means you can see bagels boiling and baking, making the anticipation even better. Everything here feels a bit more hands-on, and it shows in every bite.
I keep coming back for their plain bagel with whipped honey walnut cream cheese. The bagel’s crisp crust and soft center bring clear craftsmanship, while the cream cheese adds sweet, nutty depth. It’s an old favorite, done right every time.
Bruegger’s isn’t just about bagels; it’s the friendly staff and relaxed atmosphere that encourage you to sit back—or grab a dozen to-go. Perfect for those who appreciate tradition without pretense.
Frequently Asked Questions
Where can I find the best bagels near Fountain, CO?
You’ll find standout bagels at a mix of chain favorites and local gems, including Dunkin’, Olde World Bagel, Einstein Bros. Bagels, Coffee & Bagel Corner, and Bruegger’s. Each brings a different style, so there’s something for every taste.
Are there any traditional-style bagel shops close to Fountain?
Yes, Olde World Bagel stands out for its classic hand-rolled and boiled bagels. Their traditional approach gives each bagel a distinct chew and authentic flavor.
Can I get bagels with vegetarian spreads or fillings?
Absolutely. Most local shops, like Einstein Bros., Bruegger’s, and Olde World Bagel, offer bagels with a variety of vegetarian cream cheeses and fresh veggie toppings.
Do these places offer gluten-free options?
Gluten-free options vary by location. Some spots like Einstein Bros. occasionally offer gluten-free bagels, but it’s a good idea to call ahead to check availability.
What’s the best bagel for breakfast on the go?
For quick mornings, Dunkin’ serves a classic everything or plain bagel with veggie cream cheese that always satisfies. If you have time, Coffee & Bagel Corner and Olde World Bagel both offer hearty breakfast sandwiches that travel well.