Finding the best bagels in Long Beach, NY means more than grabbing breakfast—it’s about discovering which shop has perfected that much-loved mix of a crusty outside and a pillowy center. If you’ve spent a morning by the beach and then wandered into a sunlit shop where the scent of fresh bagels and brewed coffee lingers, you know exactly what I mean. I still remember the first time I tried a fresh sesame bagel steps away from the ocean; it changed my idea of what a bagel could be.
Long Beach has a surprising range of bagel spots, each with its own fiercely loyal following and secret recipe. Some spots are old-school, boasting lines out the door on weekend mornings; others are tucked away gems you stumble across on a stroll. Sifting through the options can feel overwhelming, but this guide puts the town’s standouts in sharp focus. Ready to join the bagel hunt?
1. Beach Bagel & Deli
Tucked just a few blocks from the sand, Beach Bagel & Deli feels like an institution in Long Beach. The bustle in the morning is proof that locals know where to find a proper bagel. Everything from the toasted poppy to the chewy plain tastes as if baked with real care.
The deli side gives Beach Bagel & Deli an edge. Bagel sandwiches here are bigger, better, and more flavorful. The classic egg and cheese on a sesame bagel never disappoints—fluffy, just salty enough, and keeps you full into the afternoon.
If you want the true vibe, try a bagel topped with the store-made tuna salad. It’s fresh, unpretentious, and somehow tastes like summer by the water.
2. Max Bialystok & Company
Walking into Max Bialystok & Company feels like stepping into pure bagel tradition. The scent of hand-rolled dough baking is a memory you’ll want to keep. Their bagels strike the ideal balance—crisp on the outside, soft at the core, and always warm by the time you unwrap them.
What sets Max Bialystok & Company apart is the care behind every batch. Bagels are made old-style, right on site, so each one is a little different and never bland. Grab one of their classic poppy or everything bagels and you’ll taste the difference immediately.
If you’re ordering, don’t miss the smoked whitefish salad on a pumpernickel bagel—it’s a favorite because it’s simple, fresh, and perfectly salty. For a true local experience, this spot never disappoints.
3. Life’s A Bagel
+1 516-889-8470
There’s a laid-back energy at Life’s A Bagel that matches the name. You walk in hungry and leave a little lighter, even with a bag packed full. Their bagels are kosher and made fresh, which makes a big difference in texture—soft inside, golden outside, and never too heavy.
The staff knows the locals by name, which tells you all you need to know about their place in the community. Their plain bagel with house-made vegetable cream cheese is a morning staple, light enough to take to the beach.
If you want to get adventurous, try a cinnamon raisin bagel toasted, with just a swipe of butter. It’s sweet, simple, and perfectly done every time.
4. Long Beach Bagel Cafe
Long Beach Bagel Cafe feels like the kind of place where your new favorite bagel is waiting behind the counter. There’s an energy here you notice right away, with the sound of bagels sliding into ovens and people chatting over their morning coffee. Each bite has that signature chew and a golden crust that seems to crackle just right.
What makes this cafe stand out is its variety and quality. Whether you want a classic sesame or something a bit more adventurous, every bagel is satisfying. I’ve come here after a swim, and the everything bagel with scallion cream cheese always hits the spot—fresh, flavorful, and filling.
The bagel sandwiches are also worth a detour. The Nova lox on a toasted bagel is a local favorite, layered with just enough cream cheese and onions to make it memorable.
5. Max Bialystok & Company, Inc.
(516) 432-5300Call
At Max Bialystok & Company, Inc., bagels aren’t just food—they’re a craft honed over years. I’ve watched the bakers hand-roll dough before sunrise, and the difference shows up in every bite. The bagels have a classic New York chew, and there’s something deeply satisfying about their golden, crackly crust.
Broad variety is part of the appeal. Whether you want onion, egg, or a simple plain, each bagel feels like it’s made just for you. Their homemade salads pair perfectly with the fresh-baked bagels, making it easy to create a lunch that’s both quick and memorable.
The egg bagel with veggie cream cheese is a game changer—soft, not too sweet, and loaded with flavor. If you come hungry, you’ll leave happy, and probably carrying a dozen for later.
6. Dunkin’
Dunkin’ delivers predictable comfort when you’re after a quick bagel fix in Long Beach. You know exactly what to expect—a hot, toasted bagel and a fresh cup of coffee anytime you need it. There’s convenience in every order, whether you rush in or use the app to skip the line.
While Dunkin’ is best known for coffee and donuts, their bagels have a loyal following. The texture is soft with a bit of bite, and irresistibly warm straight out of the oven. I stop here when time is tight and crave something filling before moving on with my day.
Order a plain or everything bagel with a schmear of cream cheese. It’s simple, quick, and hits the spot—proof that sometimes, the classic choices are best.
7. Bagelry
(516) 295-1222Call
Bagelry brings an old-school charm you feel the minute you step in. Here, bagels are never an afterthought—they’re the centerpiece, with a crisp shell and airy, flavorful inside. I’ve made more than one early stop here for a warm bag of everything bagels, fresh from the rack and still steaming.
Bagelry has a reputation for consistency. No matter when you visit, you’ll find a spread of traditional favorites and friendly faces behind the counter. The plain bagel with vegetable cream cheese is a go-to because it strikes a perfect balance, never overpowering but never plain either.
Order the onion bagel if you’re after something with a little character. It’s savory, packed with flavor, and stands up well with any of their homemade spreads.
8. Gotta Getta Bagel of Woodmere
(516) 569-6628Call
Gotta Getta Bagel of Woodmere is a destination for those who take their bagels seriously. The space is friendly and always buzzing, and the kosher-certified offerings give you confidence in quality and freshness. I’ve stopped in for a mid-morning snack and found the shelves still stacked with warm, baked-daily bagels.
What stands out is the range—from classics like sesame to seasonal twists that surprise loyal regulars. If you want a bite that feels both traditional and new, this is the spot. Their bagels are chewy, golden, and never dry.
Try their salt bagel with scallion cream cheese. The salty crust is deeply satisfying, especially paired with one of their fresh spreads. For a quick meal or a dozen to share, this spot never lets you down.
9. Bagel Boys
(516) 442-0500Call
Bagel Boys has that inviting, classic deli vibe that instantly draws you in. You’ll often find a line but it moves fast—and for good reason. Bagels here come out piping hot, boasting a crisp bite and a flavorful middle that keeps crowds coming back. My first visit turned into a regular weekend ritual pretty quickly.
There’s personality in every detail: friendly staff, fresh ingredients, and bagels that are always just the right size. The menu is simple yet stacked, focusing on what matters most—freshness, taste, and consistency.
If you’re curious, grab an everything bagel with their signature veggie cream cheese. It’s hearty without being heavy, and showcases how Bagel Boys balances classic methods with a bit of creativity.
10. Bagel Factory
Bagel Factory feels like the heart of Oceanside mornings, with locals greeting each other over coffee and fresh bagels. What sets this spot apart is the consistency—every bagel sports that iconic, slightly shiny crust and soft, flavorful crumb. I once stopped by for a quick breakfast and ended up taking a dozen home because the aroma was too tempting to resist.
The choices are broad, but the everything bagel stands out. Its topping is generous, and the flavor packs a punch without overwhelming. Pair it with their light scallion cream cheese and you understand why there’s always a steady stream of regulars.
Whether you need breakfast or a bagel for the road, Bagel Factory’s quality makes it a local favorite.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the most popular bagel shops in Long Beach, NY?
Some local favorites include Beach Bagel & Deli, Max Bialystok & Company, Life’s A Bagel, and Long Beach Bagel Cafe. Each one has its own loyal crowd and unique style.
Which Long Beach, NY bagel shops offer kosher options?
Life’s A Bagel and Gotta Getta Bagel of Woodmere offer kosher-certified bagels and spreads.
Can I get vegan or dairy-free bagels in Long Beach?
Most shops offer plain, sesame, and everything bagels that are typically vegan. Always check for dairy-free cream cheese or ask about ingredients at each shop.
Are any Long Beach bagel shops open early?
Yes, many open as early as 6:00 AM, including Beach Bagel & Deli and Max Bialystok & Company. Perfect for grabbing a bite before a morning walk on the boardwalk.
Do any of these shops offer bagel catering?
Several—including Max Bialystok & Company and Long Beach Bagel Cafe—provide catering platters for events, meetings, or beach picnics.