Finding the best bagels in New Bern, NC is a bit like going on a friendly treasure hunt. Maybe you crave that perfect chewy bite or the aroma of fresh dough with the sun streaming through a café window. I remember my first New Bern bagel: crisp on the outside, soft inside, not a trace of blandness or overwhelming salt. It didn’t scream for attention; it just delivered on what a real bagel should be.
Bagel lovers in New Bern don’t lack options, but only a few spots turn a simple breakfast roll into something worth talking about. Local favorites serve these circles of delight with attention to detail, from classic combos to surprising local twists. If you’re curious about where to find these stars of the morning, you’re in the right place. Every spot in this guide was chosen for quality, consistency, and a knack for brightening mornings. Let’s take that first bite.
Where to find the best bagels in New Bern, NC
Here are some of the top spots to find the best bagels in New Bern, NC:
1. Carolina Bagel Co & Deli
Carolina Bagel Co & Deli has a way of making you feel like a regular before you’ve even sat down. Every bagel comes with a whisper of New York nostalgia and a genuine New Bern twist. The staff moves with purpose, spreading cream cheese with a generous hand and recommending combinations that surprise even loyal locals.
What sets this place apart is its dedication to fresh-baked bagels—the everything bagel with house-made veggie cream cheese is a wake-up call done right. Vegetarian and vegan options show attention to detail without losing that classic deli charm.
For lunch, many recommend the lox and bagel platter or the hearty build-your-own breakfast sandwich. Whatever you choose, freshness is always on the menu.
2. Coastal Cravin Bagelry
Coastal Cravin Bagelry is tucked inside the Harris Teeter Shopping Center, easy to spot and worth every visit. On my first trip, the scent of warm bagels practically led me straight from the parking lot. There’s a casual, coastal vibe that makes the shop feel both homey and pleasantly bustling.
What stands out here is the variety—signature bagels like asiago, honey wheat, and jalapeño cheddar share the spotlight with classic choices. Every batch is baked fresh, giving each bagel that perfect crust and pillowy crumb. They do bagels justice, plain and simple.
Try a breakfast bagel sandwich or a unique specialty bagel. The veggie-packed garden bagel with herby cream cheese still ranks as my favorite. It’s New Bern comfort with a dash of creativity.
3. Dunkin’
Dunkin’ on Neuse Blvd proves that convenience doesn’t have to mean compromise. The bustling drive-thru is a testament to just how many locals rely on Dunkin’ for their daily fix. My early mornings sometimes start here, especially if I crave something quick and satisfying without a lengthy wait.
What sets Dunkin’ apart is consistency. Their classic plain or sesame bagel pairs well with any of their smooth cream cheese spreads. It’s a familiar choice that always tastes just how you remember, whether enjoyed in the car or at the counter.
For something a bit heartier, try a toasted bagel sandwich with egg and cheese. You get speed, freshness, and that signature Double D reliability, making Dunkin’ a dependable option in New Bern’s bagel lineup.
4. Bagels Plus Of Havelock
Bagels Plus Of Havelock might be a short drive from New Bern, but regulars know it’s worth the miles. I stopped in on a recommendation and left with a bag full of fresh bagels, each with its own story. There’s a family-run feel to the place—warm greetings, and the staff remembers your favorite order if you come more than once.
The secret here lies in their traditional approach. Hand-rolled and kettle-boiled bagels make every bite memorable. You taste the difference in texture and care; it’s classic, not flashy.
Order a bagel with their signature homemade cream cheese or go for the popular egg bagel. For anyone craving authentic flavor close to New Bern, Bagels Plus delivers precisely what you’re searching for.
More Things to Try in New Bern, NC
Frequently Asked Questions
Where can I find fresh bagels in New Bern, NC?
You’ll find fresh bagels at places like Carolina Bagel Co & Deli, Coastal Cravin Bagelry, and Dunkin’. For a broader selection or a nostalgic taste, Carolina Bagel Co is a local favorite.
Are there vegetarian or vegan bagel options in New Bern?
Yes, Carolina Bagel Co & Deli offers both vegetarian and vegan options, including dairy-free spreads. Coastal Cravin Bagelry also has a variety of veggie toppings and non-dairy alternatives.
Do any of the local bagel shops offer gluten-free bagels?
Some shops may offer gluten-free choices, but availability changes. Always call ahead to Coastal Cravin Bagelry or Carolina Bagel Co to confirm.
Where can I get a bagel sandwich in New Bern?
All major bagel shops in New Bern—especially Dunkin’ and Carolina Bagel Co—build hearty bagel sandwiches to order for breakfast or lunch.
Is there a shop open early for bagels?
Dunkin’ opens early and is perfect if you need your bagel with the sunrise. Most local bakeries also open in the morning, but check their hours for specifics.