Finding a great bagel in Tallahassee means more than just grabbing a quick breakfast. It’s about discovering a place where every bite carries a balance of fresh flavor and satisfying texture. Over the years, I’ve sampled countless bagels around the city and learned that the best spots combine quality ingredients with a touch of culinary craft.
In this guide, I’ll share the top locations to indulge in authentic, delicious bagels in Tallahassee. From classic favorites to innovative twists, these spots stand out for their consistency and flavor. Whether you crave a hearty breakfast or a snack on the go, this list is tailored to help you find the perfect bagel every time.
Where to find the best bagels in Tallahassee, FL
Here are some of the top spots to find the best bagels in Tallahassee, FL:
- Bagel Bagel
- Bruegger’s Bagels
- Bruegger’s Bagels
- New Leaf Market & Deli
- Einstein Bros. Bagels
- Universal Bagel
- Bagels & Co
- The Original Brooklyn Water Bagel Co.
- Dunkin’
- Karen’s Kitchen and Bakery
1. Bagel Bagel
Nestled on West Pensacola Street, Bagel Bagel offers a straightforward yet inviting spot for bagel enthusiasts in Tallahassee. My personal visits reveal a place that values freshness and simplicity, serving up bagels that are perfectly baked and consistently delicious. The friendly staff and cozy atmosphere make it an ideal stop for breakfast or lunch.
What truly sets Bagel Bagel apart is its commitment to quality, whether you’re ordering classic bagels or inventive toppings. Their “Everything Bagel” or the “Herb and Garlic Bagel” are highly recommended—rich in flavor and made with care. Pair your choice with cream cheese or smoked salmon for a satisfying and authentic bagel experience. It’s a spot that captures the true essence of a good bagel in Tallahassee.
2. Bruegger’s Bagels
Bruegger’s Bagels on North Monroe Street delivers a reliable dose of New York-style authenticity in the heart of Tallahassee. I’ve stopped in more times than I can count, and each visit confirms their knack for consistency. The bagels are kettle-boiled and baked fresh daily, giving them that signature chew and golden crust that sets them apart.
What makes Bruegger’s Bagels stand out is their Vermont-made cream cheese and wide selection of breakfast sandwiches. The “Farmhouse Egg Sandwich” is a personal favorite—stacked with peppered bacon, ham, cheddar, and country pepper cream cheese on a cheesy hash brown bagel. It’s hearty without being heavy.
If you’re short on time, their mobile app makes ordering ahead easy. Whether you’re craving a classic plain bagel or something more layered, this spot delivers flavor without fuss.
3. Bruegger’s Bagels
Located on Mahan Drive, Bruegger’s Bagels offers a slice of New York in Tallahassee with its freshly baked, authentic bagels every morning. My visits reveal a welcoming space where the aroma of kettle-boiled bagels signals quality and tradition. They’re perfect for any time of day, whether it’s breakfast, lunch, or a quick snack.
Their signature Vermont-made cream cheese adds a creamy richness that complements the bagels perfectly. The Breakfast Schlotzsky’s Bagel or the Ultimate Bagel Sandwich are excellent choices, loaded with fresh ingredients and crafted with care. These menu items embody the brand’s commitment to authentic flavor and quality.
For those on the go, the mobile app makes ordering ahead simple. Bruegger’s balances classic style with modern convenience, making it a standout choice for bagels in Tallahassee.
4. New Leaf Market & Deli
(850) 942-2557Call
New Leaf Market & Deli blends community spirit with clean eating, making it a refreshing stop for bagel lovers in Tallahassee. Nestled on Apalachee Parkway, this co-op grocery and deli offers a curated selection of organic and locally sourced goods that feel both intentional and nourishing.
What sets it apart is the deli’s commitment to quality. I’ve grabbed a toasted whole grain bagel layered with avocado and fresh sprouts—simple, but packed with flavor. Their bagels aren’t flashy, but they’re wholesome and satisfying, especially when paired with house-made hummus or vegan cream cheese.
Whether you’re plant-based or just bagel-curious, New Leaf’s deli menu reflects its ethos: fresh, local, and thoughtfully prepared. It’s a quiet gem for those who value substance over spectacle.
5. Einstein Bros. Bagels
Located on Wildwood Drive, Einstein Bros. Bagels offers a familiar classic with its warm, freshly baked bagels every day. My visits reveal a welcoming spot where the aroma of boiling and baking bagels makes it difficult to resist. Their selection of breakfast sandwiches and shmears adds to the appeal, making it a reliable choice for a quick, satisfying meal.
What makes Einstein Bros. stand out is their focus on quality and variety. I recommend trying the Bagel Breakfast Sandwich—it’s hearty, satisfying, and packed with fresh ingredients. Their “Baker’s Dozen” of bagels provides a perfect way to share or stock up for the week, reflecting their commitment to freshness and convenience.
Whether for breakfast or lunch, Einstein Bros. combines tradition with a modern touch, delivering flavorful, consistent bagels in Tallahassee.
6. Universal Bagel
(850) 577-3555Call
Tucked just off North Meridian Street, Universal Bagel offers a humble yet consistently impressive experience. It’s the kind of spot where the bagels speak louder than the signage. On my visit, the warm, slightly crispy exterior and pillowy center of their classic plain bagel set the tone.
What sets Universal apart is its no-nonsense approach to freshness. Bagels are baked daily, which gives the texture a satisfying bite. The staff knows their regulars and makes ordering feel casual, never rushed.
If you go, try the everything bagel with scallion cream cheese. It balances savory with subtle tang, and the seasoning never overpowers. It’s a simple order, but Universal’s execution turns it into something memorable.
Bagel lovers who appreciate quality over pretense will feel right at home.
7. Bagels & Co
Nestled on West Gaines Street, Bagels & Co offers a vibrant, welcoming atmosphere combined with consistently high-quality bagels. During my visit, I was impressed by their diverse selection and the evident care taken in every batch. The aroma of freshly baked bagels fills the air, inviting passersby to indulge.
What makes Bagels & Co stand out is their creative toppings and specialty bagels. I recommend trying the Sesame Bagel with Herb Cream Cheese. It’s flavorful, balanced, and showcases their emphasis on fresh ingredients and craftsmanship. Their variety reflects a commitment to quality that keeps regular customers returning.
Whether for breakfast or a quick lunch, Bagels & Co balances convenience with flavor. It’s a place where simplicity meets excellence, perfect for bagel aficionados in Tallahassee.
8. The Original Brooklyn Water Bagel Co.
The Original Brooklyn Water Bagel Co. brings a distinct New York vibe to Tallahassee with its signature water filtration process that mimics Brooklyn’s legendary water. It’s a clever touch that adds authenticity to every bite.
Located on West Madison Street, the shop offers a cozy interior and friendly service. I dropped in mid-morning and found the atmosphere relaxed, with locals sipping coffee and working through warm, fresh bagels. There’s a genuine sense of community here.
The standout is the Everything Bagel paired with Scallion Cream Cheese. Its crisp exterior and flavorful blend of seeds deliver balance and depth. Their coffee also deserves mention—strong, smooth, and perfectly paired with any order.
Brooklyn Water Bagel Co. is ideal for those seeking quality without pretension. It’s approachable, dependable, and quietly excellent.
9. Dunkin’
Dunkin’ at Thomasville Road might be known for coffee, but don’t overlook its dependable bagels. Whether you’re grabbing breakfast before work or fueling up post-jog, it delivers simplicity done right.
I stopped in midweek around 8 a.m.—quick service, fresh aroma, and no frills. The crowd? Regulars who know what they want. I joined them with a Plain Bagel toasted with cream cheese, crisp on the outside, pillowy in the middle. No mystery, just comfort.
For a little variety, the Multigrain Bagel offers a hearty bite that holds up well with veggie cream cheese. It’s subtle, not showy, but that’s Dunkin’s style—reliable, accessible, and consistent across the board.
Pair it with their bold Original Blend Coffee and you’ve got a morning routine that’s hard to beat. No gimmicks, just good staples done fast.
10. Karen’s Kitchen and Bakery
(850) 745-6289Call
Karen’s Kitchen and Bakery in Crawfordville offers a cozy, family-friendly atmosphere with a reputation for fresh baked goods. During my visit, I was greeted with warm smiles and the enticing aroma of freshly baked bagels and pastries. Their selection emphasizes quality and homemade charm.
What makes Karen’s Kitchen and Bakery stand out is their attention to detail. I recommend trying their Cinnamon Raisin Bagel with cream cheese—it’s naturally sweet and perfectly baked. Their variety of baked goods, from pies to wedding cakes, reflects their dedication to craftsmanship.
Whether for breakfast or dessert, their bagels are a delightful blend of flavor and freshness. It’s a place where tradition and care shine through in every bite.
More Things to Try in Tallahassee, FL
Frequently Asked Questions
Where can I find the best bagels in Tallahassee?
You’ll find top-rated bagels at Bagel Bagel, Bruegger’s Bagels, and Bagels & Co. Each offers a distinct style—from New York-inspired classics to creative breakfast melts.
Are there any local bagel shops in Tallahassee?
Yes. Bagel Bagel and Universal Bagel are locally owned and known for fresh, made-daily bagels and breakfast options.
Do any bagel shops offer vegan or vegetarian options?
Most places like New Leaf Market & Deli and Einstein Bros. Bagels offer vegetarian bagels and spreads. Vegan options may be limited, so it’s best to check menus or ask in-store.
Which bagel shop is best for breakfast on the go?
Dunkin’ and Einstein Bros. Bagels are ideal for quick service and portable breakfast sandwiches. They also offer mobile ordering and drive-thru options.
Are there any gluten-free bagels available?
Some shops like New Leaf Market & Deli may carry gluten-free options, though availability can vary. It’s recommended to call ahead or check online menus.
Do any bagel shops offer catering services?
Yes. Bruegger’s Bagels and Bagel Bagel provide catering for breakfast meetings, events, and group orders.
Which bagel shop has the most variety?
Bruegger’s Bagels stands out with a wide selection including Asiago Parmesan, Rosemary Olive Oil, and Jalapeño Cheddar.
Are there any bagel shops near Florida State University?
Yes. Bagels & Co and Einstein Bros. Bagels are located close to campus and popular with students.